Critical response
On the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, 21% of 92 critics' reviews are positive, with an average rating of 4.5/10. The website's consensus reads: "Overloaded with quirk and recycled twists, Holland's impressive style can't paper over a hollow script." Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned the film a score of 42 out of 100, based on 20 critics, indicating "mixed or average" reviews.
Peter Debruge of Variety described Holland as a film that immerses viewers primarily in its protagonist's perspective, which, while not entirely believable, offers an entertaining experience for audiences who enjoy the tension of questioning whether the character is unstable or the sole voice of reason. Chase Hutchinson of The Wrap praised Kidman's performance by noting that she is one of the most versatile and daring performers in modern cinema, often underappreciated despite her immense talent.
Glenn Garner of Deadline Hollywood praised the cast's performance. He said Kidman delivers a sharp, manic performance in the film, evoking the darkly comedic tone of Gus Van Sant's To Die For, complete with biting humor and a gripping mystery in a portrayal that, he said, reminds audiences why she has remained a captivating force in cinema for decades. William Hosie of London Evening Standard admired the cast's performance, especially Kidman, saying this role not only showcases Kidman's remarkable range but also reaffirms her ability to breathe life into uniquely compelling characters, further solidifying her status as one of the most versatile actresses of her generation.
Lovia Gyarkye of The Hollywood Reporter said that the true standout of Holland is Cave's distinctive style, which masterfully crafts an unsettling vision of suburban discomfort. In a similar view, Adrian Horton of The Guardian said that while Holland excels in its striking visuals and the eerie, unsettling atmosphere crafted by Cave, there's a noticeable disconnect between these strengths and the film's narrative, which feels as fragile and insubstantial as one of Nancy's delicate Dutch hats.
