Legal issues
On June 12, 2010, Margera was allegedly attacked with a baseball bat outside his bar, The Note. Margera spent the night at Crozer-Chester Medical Center, where he was treated for head injuries. According to the alleged assailant, Elizabeth Ray, the altercation began because Margera allegedly called her a "nigger". However, Ray denies physically attacking Margera. Margera has since denied having ever said the word, claiming "I called her a crazy bitch and an idiot, but I definitely didn't use the n-word".
In July 2013, Margera was arrested at Keflavík Airport in Iceland, having left the country without paying damages following a rental car dispute the year before. Margera had rented a Toyota Land Cruiser during a vacation in Iceland in 2012, which he had returned in "terrible shape" five days later, but left the country before paying for the damage. Margera was released later the same day after paying the outstanding fees, and admitted in an interview that he had trashed the car in a drunken stupor.
On March 2, 2023, Margera was arrested for domestic violence, after he allegedly kicked a woman. He was released from custody after he posted a $50,000 bail the next day. On April 23, 2023, police were dispatched to Margera's home after he allegedly made death threats to his brother, Jess, and subsequently punched him in the face. Margera reportedly fled on foot into the woods when police arrived. After being on the run for three days and allegedly making several threatening phone calls to his family, Margera eventually surrendered to Pennsylvania Police. Later, Margera released a statement saying the allegations made by his brother, Jess, were false.
Around June 7, 2023, Margera was placed on 5150 psychiatric hold at a Los Angeles mental health facility, following disturbing text messages Margera had been sending family members, and erratic speech and behavior when he was located by police.
Additionally, Margera encountered further legal issues in Delaware County when he was arrested for public intoxication and disorderly conduct. Prosecutors questioned whether his bail should be revoked due to these incidents, prompting Margera to appear before Judge Patrick Carmody and pledge his commitment to sobriety. The judge allowed Margera to remove his ankle bracelet temporarily to assess his alcohol use, with a warning of consequences for any future violations.
During a January 2021 interview, Margera revealed that owing to his behavior over the last few years, Jackass co-creator Jeff Tremaine had to fight with the studio to keep Margera in the next Jackass film, Jackass Forever (2022), and that Margera still was not certain that Paramount Pictures was ultimately going to allow him to partake in the filming of the movie, and that it all depended on his sobriety and behavior. On February 11, 2021, Margera posted several videos to his Instagram account, in which he admitted to breaking his sobriety, and indicated that he had been fired from the filming of Jackass Forever, which was officially confirmed soon after. Throughout the video, he could be seen crying, vomiting, and alluding to having looked up "how to tie a noose" before his move to Oceanside, California.
Margera alleged that Paramount had been forcing him to take antidepressants, submit to random urine tests, and had forced him to check in to two different rehabilitation facilities using his own money. He also expressed great disdain for Tremaine, Johnny Knoxville, and Spike Jonze before asking his fans to boycott Jackass Forever, as well as to send him money so he could shoot his own movie to compete with the film. All of the videos were removed from Margera's Instagram account shortly after being posted.
On May 25, 2021, it was reported that Jeff Tremaine had filed a temporary restraining order against Margera, due to the latter's harassment of both Tremaine and Knoxville via Instagram. Tremaine was granted an additional three-year restraining order, extended to Tremaine's wife and children, after Margera allegedly sent the family death threats. On August 9, 2021, Margera filed a lawsuit against Tremaine, Knoxville, Jonze, Paramount, MTV, Dickhouse Entertainment, and Gorilla Flicks, alleging that he was wrongfully fired from the production of Jackass Forever.
On January 12, 2022, Knoxville said that, despite the ongoing lawsuit, Margera would still appear in Jackass Forever in one scene he filmed for the movie prior to him being fired. All parties eventually came to a settlement after Margera asked to dismiss the lawsuit on April 14, 2022. The terms of the settlement remain private. Margera eventually appeared in the film in one scene filmed before his termination, as well as being heard in another scene and in archival footage.
Following the settlement, Margera ruled out any future involvements with his former Jackass colleagues or any future Jackass projects, claiming that Knoxville and Tremaine "ruined the legacy" of the franchise. However, he still remains on good terms with the rest of the cast and crew.
On January 8, 2026, Jackass: Best and Last was officially announced by Knoxville, and was released theatrically on June 26, 2026. Due to his experience on Jackass Forever, Margera stated that he will not film any new material for the upcoming film. However, he gave the filmmakers consent to include him through old archive, and unused footage. He was invited to the red carpet premiere of Jackass: Best and Last, but declined the offer due to a prior engagement. Despite this, he still wished for the films' success.